um [Music] so [Music] good afternoon mayor you are live okay good afternoon everybody welcome to the joint meeting of the las cruces planning and zoning commission and the las cruces city council today is tuesday april 13th 2021 it's approximately 303 pm before we get started if you would please rise for the pledge of allegiance pledge allegiance to the flag the united states and to the republic for which it stands one nation under god indivisible with liberty and justice for all god blessed america and so i'm going to turn it over to uh our director of community development mr larry nichols is going to kind of start off everything so larry you want to do that and also for our city council and planning zoning members i'm going to ask that the presentation in its entirety and then we'll have questions okay all right larry thank you mayor for the record larry nicholas community development director and i want to recognize and thank the city council and the members of the planning and zoning commission for attending this meeting today uh the meeting is going to be a kind of an update and a report on the progress that has been made on the east loma development plan and in particular what has been uh noted in your agenda as the preferred plan and meaning that this is the one that the consultant has taken in and developed into what we believe will meet folks desires and expectations the city staff in attendance this afternoon will be myself tim pitts dave ware catherine harrison rodgers and um and mark miller we have our consultant with us at site southwest and i'll ask them to introduce themselves and begin their presentation and with that i yield the floor to side southwest thank you good afternoon larry good afternoon mayor and city council and all of the planning and zoning commissioners that are here we're really happy to have you here uh we've been working hard on excuse me sir i'm sorry can you just state your name again i'm sorry uh mayor uh my name is george radnovich and i am a principal with sites southwest we also have with us and i'll let everybody introduce themselves starting with danny good afternoon everyone my name is danny wilson i'm a planner with sight southwest and i apologize if there's a bit of an echo on my end i'm sorry that was sandy uh danielle wilson oh danny wilson okay welcome next hi everyone my name is mario nino whalen and i'm on the landscape architecture team here at south southwest okay thank you hi i'm jay narina i'm on the sites of this team i'm at the firm called civic plan studio we are planners urban designers working with site southwest on this team i'm michael houston i'm an architect and urban planner with civic plan studio also and part of the site southwest team i'm sorry michael your last name again was houston but it's spelled h-u-s-t-o-n not like the city okay thanks everyone and thank you uh mayor and city council and planning and zoning commissioners we're really excited to show you where the plans come uh we're gonna kind of whip through uh very fairly quickly the background since oh got it sorry about that through the background uh slides and really get to the meat of the matter which is uh the preferred scenario plan and again this is in draft form so for those of you who are seeing this in the public uh as well as city council and and uh plenty of zoning commissioners and the mayor it is a draft you'll see that it's sketchy and we wanted to keep it that way purposely at this point so that we could still hear comments on it i know it's the first time you're seeing the plan since you saw the three scenarios the last time we met and we really want to get your input on the plan so the goal and danny if you could go to the next slide the goal of today's presentation is really to present you with this preferred plan and to hear from all of you the the what we're going to do on the on the entire presentation today is is briefly go through the project context and the process summary that we have made for you we're going to review the community engagement community engagement that we've had to date and go through some of those preferences that the community of las cruces had on the project thus far then we're going to show you the preferred plan and then we'll have next steps and discussion from that so the first thing we're going to do is just provide a little context for anyone who hasn't seen the plan as of now and and uh we'll go through this briefly as i mentioned so this slide shows the context of the community that will make up this east loman development plan area it's very close to a lot of amenities in las cruces including the las cruces dam which is walking distance and that open space behind it the las cruces airfield and air park as well as the composting center and all of the other amenities that the city provides in that open space to the east of the project area and it's also walking distance and very close to the new east mesa public recreation complex which will be actually going to bid in the next week um very close also to uh the communities to the south and the north in terms of neighborhoods and it's kind of surrounded by uh by the city on the west the north and the south next slide this plan wasn't developed in a vacuum we did review at great length elevate las cruces which you all approved last year and the plan area was shown on the elevate las cruces plan you'll see it right where it says project area on the right-hand side of this slide what we took from elevate las cruces and in and included in our planning was a mix of of residential uses from uh the very uh the very densely populated to the least densely populated residential neighborhoods um we also took that we are going to be going to be providing a buffer from existing communities in our land planning and that along with the mix of residential uses will also provide a mixed use uh in the entire area for not just residential uses but uh other land uses such as retail commercial and health related improvements next slide we also looked at the lowman avenue plan which was developed in the year 2000 i know it's old but it still has quite a bit of relevance and we've highlighted our plan area in orange or that kind of uh ochre color on the right-hand side what the loman plan did do is establish this area as a gateway district it also established design guidelines and they were for architecture they were also about the landscape and visual interest and then the massing of building buildings within the area and we've taken that to heart as well and that it create a real live work and shop environment with a mix of land uses and we've also taken that to heart as well in our planning this slide looks a little bit like the first one the differences are that it's really relative to transportation and so what we're showing in this slide is existing transportation and approved transportation corridors and proposed transportation corridors and the corridors are both for active transportation like bicycling hiking and walking but also vehicular transport and even bus transport and you can see by the little blue dot that's at the far west end of our development area that is the transfer center uh for the uh uh busing that will uh the public busing that will arrive at the site and we'll show you a little bit more about that uh in a in a little while um another thing we took from the active transportation planning that the city has already done is that 50 57 of the people appreciate bike lanes and want bike lanes on east lowman so we took that to heart as well in our planning efforts this plan shows in a little more detail and in a zoomed in kind of view the area that we've mostly been planning what it's showing is opportunities for the area based on the land itself and what we know about it so those red areas those red polygons are showing steeply steeply sloped sites so those are those kind of hills and and the slope going up to the top of those hills around the site both on the south near the little dam arroyo and on the north near loman the other thing it's showing is that we will provide a buffer and that's shown in that kind of kind of uh earth color to the south along the edge of the arroyo and it also acknowledges that the little dam arroyo is there as well as the south las cruces arroyo it also shows that foothills drive is already planned into the site however we'll show you how we're suggesting it be modified and it shows you where those views are towards the organ mountains which are so supreme and it didn't get to this slide but the views towards the roblox are also a really important part of the site the orange line shows the existing alignment of foothills drive so you can see we're not proposing to change it very much in our planning and then that lighter lime green color right in the middle of the site is showing that kind of hilltop area along the top of the hill uh where the village center uh will be for our our land uses and the suggested land uses that we'll have for the for the area so this is kind of a combination slide and what it's showing is some of what the team on the retail and market analysis side developed and some of what we took as our kind of goal or our vision for the area and you can see it's divided into three pieces those pieces were developed based on that market study and the market study told us that twenty percent of that site should be devoted to retail office and or hospitality like hospitals excuse me like hotels um so that twenty percent primarily and in a very general way is is towards the lowman side of the project another thing it told us is that 80 of the sites should be residential and so what we've developed are two types of residential for the most part but they're divided into four sale pieces and then for rent pieces and what we decided on with your help is that about 50 percent of the site will be devoted to the missing middle a little bit higher density we're not talking about four and five stories but we're talking about a higher density than typical residential and we've got some ideas for that and then about 30 of that 80 percent that's left would be detached residential more similar to uh uh the subdivision to the south and those neighborhoods to the north so those units are shown at the at the left hand side of this slide and those were all based on the uh the market study that rc elko provided for us so now i'm going to turn it over to danny and she is going to describe the community engagement that we've had so far on the project danny thank you george appreciate that um so in addition to conducting these analyses excuse me danny i know he's he introduced you but can you just state your name you just need to just say your name you don't have to say who you're with but just your name by all means i'm danny wilson uh and it is really a joy to be here this afternoon presenting this plan um and really excited to build on what we've already engaged which i'll summarize just briefly here so we wanted to make sure that the east loman plan is a plan that is for and by the community and that their goals their needs are really embedded into the outcome that you'll see today so to summarize some of those pieces of engagement that we've engaged in so far back in august we had several stakeholder meetings with key folks from the area including businesses and realtors developers economic development representatives and neighbors this culminated after we conducted the existing conditions analysis with a work session which was held with city council in november building on this it segued nicely into a community charrette that we held in december over the course of three days and then finalized in a shared plan on the fourth day shared three plans on the fourth day in january um and also happening concurrently during this time we launched our project website planning schloman.com where we would share regular updates with the public about plan development ways that folks could engage and then finally as we begin to move further along in the process we'll share updated plans as well um in addition to this we we had a vision survey that was open through the month of december and into january uh over 370 people responded to that survey and you'll see a quick summary of the results from that survey here in the next few slides so starting quickly some of the feedback that we heard during that community charette again this was a pretty intensive four-day period where we quickly took the ideas of the community iterated onto them and developed three design scenarios which you'll see shortly so these were the three ideas which may be familiar to some of you who participated in those days the first scenario really centered on this idea of population health so creating a plan that revolved around a healthy village concept providing lots of services to folks for that enabled healthy living and movement through the space it's building on again those adjacencies to the mountain view regional medical center there the second idea was more of a traditional neighborhood so this one was really structured in a way that promoted a lot of missing middle housing there was a central green a promenade that really acted as a spine for the plan itself so that people could gather and use that shared space and then the third scenario was the conservation neighborhood which was really focusing on how to preserve and maintain the natural habitat and drainage flows within the site so you'll see it's rather small but this arroyo and then also these drainage sections that sort of finger up into the site in a way that allows us to maintain those even around the existing development so this slide here in addition to the three scenarios we introduced nine ideas for different design concepts that we could incorporate to any one of those plans and these ideas you'll see listed here very lightly looking at again that focus on health this pedestrian village concept so enabling uh the housing and and uh commercial features to be mixed in a way that people could easily walk and bike throughout this space without having to access their car similarly the micro mobility loop is another method that we thought might help to move people throughout the space without having to access their vehicle jumping down to the promenade again that's that idea of creating a green shared space that allows us to also preserve those really nice linear views of the organ mountains off to the east this terraced entry was an idea where we were beginning to address that steep slope where the site meets east loman avenue in a way that allows us to both preserve that and not just cut right into the the side of that slope and also create a really nice usable space out of it um the missing middle housing i won't go into too much detail because we're going to talk about that a bit more later but again it's that idea of incorporating this housing that's sort of somewhere between an apartment complex and single-family residential the habitat preservation is again that maintenance of the arroyos and drainages and the environment that is so lovely in that natural desert landscape and then the detached residential is more single-family housing more traditional that we see there and then the neighborhood center is this idea where you're bringing people together in around a commercial development that perhaps takes the parking and relegates it to a different area so you're pulling the buildings up to the street and creating uh really lovely shared spaces and community spaces that can be used there by pedestrians and not just emphasizing the needs of the vehicle within that space and these preferences were ranked actually during the community meeting so the five was the highest preference score where i love this idea this is this was the idea and the one indicated that people were not too crazy about the idea and you can see that all of these ideas ranked over that neutral position where people were in favor of them um but then a few rows to the top including this preservation of the uh the arroyos and the habitat looking at the neighborhood center the missy middle housing and then also the pedestrian village and then finally we wanted to see if this i this site was a good idea for a few other ideas that we had um again that mixed income housing ranked high for folks middle missy middle and mixed income housing and people really wanted to make use of that natural topography again and then we asked for an overall ranking of those scenario ideas and we saw that that population health was really the winner here followed very closely by the conservation neighborhood and then very briefly i'm just going to summarize a few highlights from those vision survey results which was open for just over a month and we received uh 370 responses there from community members and so this is just a quick summary of a few of the uh open-ended suggestions that we had from folks and it really reinforces some of these ideas that we've already talked about where we're thinking about drainage we're thinking about traffic um we're creating meaningful places for people to gather and hang out safely we're focusing on that missy middle housing and you'll see that show up here in the next few slides so when thinking about safety in particular people are really in favor of having buffered bike lanes and sidewalks separated from the streets especially along east lowman and when asking about pedestrian facilities what makes the most sense to allow for that safe crossing people are in favor of the lighted crosswalk with the refuge to ensure a safe crossing and then when just thinking about the appropriate scale of development especially as we're getting closer to the lowman corridor um folks are in favor of a mix of stories so one to four stories but making sure it's sort of stepped back um to really be sensitive to the street front and then also adjacent development and then finally when it comes to different types of development and amenities that folks want to see restaurants with outdoor dining was the overwhelming favored response here and so finally this brings me to uh the vision that we've arrived at for the east loman area and it's really to do a few things here a few goals um one is to build on those existing medical uses making uh use of these adjacencies with our neighbors and the hospital developments to the north the second is to provide that mix of housing types and really make sure that it accommodates a range of a range of um incomes and then also a range of ages so different life stages will be able to find a place within east sloman we're integrating with the existing terrain and creating natural trails along those um and then finally of course we're building in a way that is healthy and sustainable to overall create this mixed-use neighborhood center that serves both the area of resident needs and also those regional visitor needs and with that i'll hand it over to mike to talk a little bit more about that preferred plan thanks danny great thank you danny once again i'm michael houston and uh next slide please so this is our our current plan and and again this is kind of a work in progress in fact we hadn't planned on kind of having this intermediate uh meeting at this point but folks at the city wisely thought that it was good for you guys to see this plan even though it's in progress and to give us some comments before we get too far so the plan shows uh the streets in in white and then we've color coded some of the general uses and i want to point out that because you've got a very well connected street uh grid and open space grid the the uses can kind of be a little bit flexible and they can move from kind of one zone to the other so even though we've color coded the plan it's not necessarily set in stone next slide please and then these are the ways that we've incorporated elements of the the vision statement that danny just read so you know connecting to the existing medical uses so we've clustered those purple areas our medical related uses kind of clustered those as close as possible to the existing hospital next we've really focused on housing options the missing middle and some detached residential thinking that the higher density housing could maybe go kind of on top of the ridge or the mesa if you will and then we would transition to smaller scale as we move towards the neighborhood to the south next and then incorporating the natural environment so utilizing the arroyo and kind of extending it up into the plan was very important and you'll see that we've drawn in sketched in some trail networks that could be used so you could actually be on a bike in the arroyo and and bike ride or walk right into the neighborhood and connect through the neighborhood next and then creating this uh neighborhood center and we think uh paseo de oniate has a lot of potential to be kind of a really nice neighborhood gathering place that could serve the neighborhoods of the south but really to to all the neighborhoods around the area next and this is just an annotated plan so i'll i'll go through it really quickly starting from the west so you can see down on the on the far west end we've extended road runner and thought that that was the good location for the the transit uh center uh the transfer center and we used utilized uh one of your existing facilities to determine the size of that so that's what we've shown there and also you could put the building kind of on the end and as you come down road runner you would have a nice civic building there at the end of the axis you'll see the we have three potential hotel sites uh we don't know if we're gonna have one or two hotels uh but we thought that the hotels needed to be around uh lowman clustered around loman and onyonte where they'd have more visibility uh moving up uh to the east and north you'll see again the the medical uses there and we've we also had in some of the other plans this idea of a terrorist gateway which we think is really important instead of cutting into the hillside if you remember we're proposing to do a nice landscape entrance drive that would actually go up to the top of the hill and you would have most of the development kind of sitting up there kind of looking down on lowen which i think would be really nice another element that we've incorporated is is what we've labeled an urban block so we don't think there's enough you know retail to do blocks and blocks of kind of mixed use and sense of development but we're thinking if we could get one really nice uh urban block that maybe has some sandwich places and restaurants maybe on the ground floor and something else above that would be really nice and it kind of hooks into the green space and then to focus on the the central green space so this was an element that kind of transformed from the promenade scheme if you remember the promenade scheme had a very long linear green that was uh oriented towards the mountains so in this version we thought in terms of implementation it might be better to kind of condense that into a small park or a square but it still has you see it kind of flares out towards the east so we're looking at the views of the mountains so when you come into that green space you'd actually have a nice view of the mountains there next slide please and then uh up in the upper left are are some of the programmatic elements that the marketing study identified so starting with the health services 20 to 40 000 square feet of health services i think actually we've shown a little bit more than that on our plan but again those uses can kind of fluctuate because of the block structure that we've set up um 120 to 240 key hotels so that's either one or two hotels some mixed use uh or some mixed commercial so we really kind of concentrated the commercial down on onyate and and the corner of onyate and and loman but also there's a potential there's the large site up at the northeast corner they could also have some of this commercial activity again the transit center is there the missing middle housing and the detached housing are in the orange and yellow and of course plenty of open space to kind of tie it all together next and then if you remember the the nine big ideas so we had three big ideas per plan and since everybody liked all of those ideas we were tasked with kind of combining those nine into this plan so i think we've done a pretty good job of taking those ideas that people liked and finding a place for them in this new plan so everything from the neighborhood center to the terrorist entry to the focus on health the missing middle all of those elements i think we can incorporate into this final version and i believe that's where i hand off yes thank you thank you thanks mike um my name is mario nuno whalen and i'll be talking about plane identity a little bit and what we want to do in this section is highlight some of the layers to the plan and some of the ideas that we think are really unique to this to this development could be very unique to this planning area um and if move forward really provide an identity for the east london area and just to remind uh reiterate a lot of these were came from those big ideas that we presented to the public and then really worked um moved forward with the ones that worked well with the site so we'll go through some of the oh yeah let's just jump into it so this shows um what some an example of what that missing middle housing could look like and especially in the area that mike identified as the pedestrian village or the the village neighborhood so you can see this could be composed of smaller units either one or two story clustered around these pedestrian passages um with uh and this is showing four different four different housing types on just a 30 by 40 foot footprint and so just on that small footprint you could these could be you could get everything from a 900 foot cottage all the way to 2000 square foot home so using a very small small development space a lot of options with the missing middle housing next slide please and then this showing some views of what that pedestrian village might look like and you can see the the various housing types clustered together um and in this this one like what we're showing at the north of the site the field would be if we kept cars to the sides or maybe cars at the rears of the buildings that allows for these ample open spaces you can see the sort of small private open spaces in front of each building and then these large gathering areas that are well shaded and provide a lot of community space next slide please and then here's a just a few examples of other developments that have uh that show a variety of housing options um so one we have the sivano community in tucson and in sivano they they really built in or leaned into this idea of being a desert community um prioritizing open space and trails sustainable architecture and at the same time they integrated mixed use with some commercial areas and civic areas there's like there's a such as a school in the community and then there's the montessio development in el paso another live work play community that successfully integrated mixed use and they have options like condos townhouses apartments and then they have various options some for rent and some for purchase cul-de-sac is one that's currently in progress in tempe just outside phoenix and they've really leaned into this idea of a car free community so there it's um they've kept all of sort of the streets and parking on the exterior of the community and then created these completely pedestrian walking communities and live work areas within the interior and then the last one here holidays in boulder and the plan graphic here at the top shows what holiday looks like and as you can see with holiday what they've done really well is really tried to provide a mix of housing types for various income levels so on the graphic here you can see the red is the commercial yellow is mixed use the blue is attached residential housing and then the lighter green areas are the single family or more traditional single family so they've really mixed it mixed it together and built these around these sort of shared open spaces next please and then uh the last or one of the other layers we wanted to talk about that we think is um a strong asset to the east lowman area is this idea of connectivity so to show the active transportation plan again here um you can see the east loman slated for uh separated bike lanes and um improvements there's already quite a few trails in the area and then there's our plans plans for expanding those that trail network so improved trails along the south las cruces arroyo um in the las cruces dam and then there's already a multi-use path going up the north end of sonoma ranch so we wanted to really get a sense of where the connectivity exists currently and then bring that into the the planning area so you can see on the next slide so zooming in this shows sort of an overlay of the street network and the active transportation network that we're envisioning for the east loman area so along east slomon you'd have the separated bike lanes and then coming along paseo de onate which goes down to the canyon point community proposed bike lanes along there and then that central corridor that runs right through the sites also having bike lanes and then really providing an extensive network of multi-use trails and this can be a range of options so very naturalistic bike path type trails along the uh arroyo to the south and then using the existing arroyos as open space providing trail networks that really connect both the community to the south and residents and users within the sloman area to the central and commercial corridors next please and this section shows what that might look like so this is a section of east loma but this is applicable to some of the um many of the shared streets in the planning areas you can see really trying to integrate the topography of the site and capture storm water where possible so green medians in between lanes and then using the sides of the streets for bio swales with landscape improvements providing as much shade as possible and then creating these safe buffered bike lanes and walking areas from the outskirts next slide please and then as we talked about in the uh um big ideas scenario this is big ideas that were presented in the three different options um we wanted to show what that micro mobility loop might look like overlaid on the preferred plan and um this this sort of builds on the a growing trend of folks having a kind of a growing appetite for transit and alternative transportation options and maybe less attachment to personal cars and needing to drive everywhere so thinking about autonomous vehicles and small shuttles within the site as well as these scooters shared bikes e-bikes and so this could this shows where how that might work on the site so we'd have stops at the transit center these commercial shopping areas commercial corridors hotel medical center and then bringing it over into the more residential components of the site next slide please and the idea with this is the micro mobility loops these can expand sort of as development expands within the site so as things move northward or as the as the plane grows extending that loop to include walmart and the medical offices north and east of the existing medical center and then future shopping areas along sonoma ranch and then lastly just wanted to highlight the layer of open space areas in the plan and i think we going through the different draft scenarios and getting feedback from folks and how a lot of people really liked having density on the one hand but loved what the the conservation um the conservation plan did in terms of building around the existing drainages and the uh preserving the the healthy landscapes we tried to cluster housing the the detached housing around these arroyos and build these communities so that they responded to that and allow trail networks to go in there so you can see the largest royal down to the south and then various green spaces using the smaller drainages that come down from foothills drive the sort of central gathering park the central park of the mixed use area and then folks really responded to the terraced entry and so using that as a as a mix of green spaces this could be pocket parks this could be small little gathering areas that maybe the medical center staff and visitors could use and then the last one being the existing drainage basin building upon the existing drainage basin that runs along roadrunner and taking that a step further into a shared green space and i will hand it over to jay thank you thanks mario uh again my name is jay narayana i'm going to be presenting uh the zoning framework again uh we have this great vision for this development on east sloman a lot of the property is owned by the city so the city does have some control but the idea is that we don't want this vision to just remain on the shelf we want to make sure that it can be implemented through a zoning framework um that's based on uh you know leveraging the market potential allowing some flexibility but really balancing the need for some predictability of of development because as uh as the city sells or disposes of property you want to make sure that everyone is playing from the same uh uh blueprint and there is value that's added for everyone building on an overall vision so next slide so a lot of what you have around here is is very familiar it's what's on the left where you have buildings that are set back and parking is in front of the building and along the roadways so and the vision we want to achieve is really what's on the right where the buildings are closer to the street and you have parking behind so how do we get from what's on the left to the right so it's really about reframing how we look look at zoning and looking at the form of development that's implemented next slide so on the left you have single use buildings that are set back uh parking along the roadways it's it's mainly auto oriented so if you think about east loman right now it's fairly auto oriented if you're on the street uh walking on lowman most people maybe think that your car broke down somewhere and you really have no business walking on the roadway uh but we want to make it uh more easy to to walk and attract multiple modes as you talked about this great investment of the multimobility loop and and also the trails and and the city has a big investment on this property and and the need for realizing the potential for a lot of users and making sure that that's implemented um next slide so the idea of of zoning uh we're looking at it more on off of a form based code a type zoning framework that establishes different character areas or different uh zones that have different forms the whole east loman district is uh is one district but not uh it's not a one size fits all zoning tool you do have different nuances of different use types and different intensities of development uh based on where you are the neighborhood center may take a different feel um the the neighborhood that's the detached housing may look different and feel different we want to make sure that there is some street connectivity that's thought of that as development happens you actually end up with a connected street network and in pedestrian network there is a lot of detail in our vision so we want to make sure a lot of that is translated through the zoning tool next slide um so you remember this is the preferred scenario if you think about how we would go about creating the the zoning framework for this uh scenario the next sign um the so one area would be the civic uh that we are treating it a little bit differently because it is a unique um use that's a bus transfer station which is uh which is a public use we know that there are some special needs in terms of circulation for the buses connectivity that's needed uh with the the light there at road runner so uh next time uh then the lowman gateway the reason we are identifying this as a different character area is because we want to make sure that the intensity of the development maybe this is where we have the highest intensity of development maybe it's five story because it is kind of lower down on the hill uh we want uh this intersection to kind of create almost uh an interesting uh um um um kind of landmark uh for east sloman uh so people know that you're in a special area um so you'd want a mix of all kinds of uses including the hotel commercial health related mixed use and residential next so this would be the kind of development that we're envisioning so when you translate the zoning tool we would want to make sure that the design standards would implement some version of this it won't exactly be like this but we want to make sure that the elements here are reflected next and the health campus we know this is going to be fairly unique it may be one developer who comes forward it may be it may include senior living some commercial office doctors offices other health related uses that we we don't uh really have a crystal ball to envision right now next line uh again it could include some institute institutional uses but also residential uh these are some images of what that kind of development could look like next uh and the neighborhood itself uh that's the mixed uh missing middle neighborhood we talked about the um the examples of tempeh arizona and and uh with cul-de-sac or savannah or or montesail we want to make sure those precedence and the design standards for that are translated into zoning it may be height standards for three story on top of the mesa there on the highest point of the site um and then maybe some smaller scale commercial development when mike described the whole idea of having restaurants and more of an urban block closer to the health campus that not maybe a location where you focus some ground floor commercial uses in your zoning next this could be the image of what that the village neighborhood could look like it's a mix of missing metal and commercial uses next and the last would be the detached residential neighborhood the idea for this is to match the scale of the residential neighborhood which is single family but allowing a little more gentle density it could be one to four units duplexes triplexes but still keeping with the scale of the neighborhood maybe it's a two-story maximum having maybe some larger lots some smaller lots maybe accessory dwelling units and really having a mix but that's more um compatible with the neighborhood to the south next so this would be the image of what the standards would implement next uh with that i'll hand it over to mike to talk about the next steps thank you that's me okay next michael houston again here so i think we have just two slides but um what we did is uh when you're talking about implementation it helps to break out the plan into its two basic components so in urban planning we always think of the civic realm or the public realm which includes the streets and open spaces and infrastructure and then the private realm which is the development that happens within the private property boundaries so to help with the implementation we've got one slide that kind of highlights the different components of the civic realm and we've numbered those there so really the next step needs to be or we recommend is that you think about doing some very preliminary engineering and study of these different infrastructure components uh probably the most important would be the east loman corridor uh where you look at the separated bike lanes that have been identified in the earlier plans and the feasibility of this kind of terrorist entryway and you don't want to obviously go directly into full blown engineering you just need to do enough to get a handle on the feasibility and the cost and and you know knowing the cost getting an estimate on that is like a big step in in getting it implemented and then another component would be uh paseo oreo we've we've indicated a need for bike lanes and sidewalks as part of the redevelopment there if we get some neighborhood commercial along there foothill drives is kind of a different animal you could go ahead and do some very preliminary engineering and design on that portion now or you could kind of put that off and let's say one developer comes along to do this whole neighborhood area that could come later as part of that private development so it's kind of in the in the middle zone and that would be the same with the arroyo i think you could do some preliminary engineering now or you could kind of put that off until the residential component of the development happens um so so again loman and onyate are kind of the two key elements that we think needs more study in the short term rather than the long term next and then within the private realm this kind of goes back to what uh jay had just talked about um so it's putting in place a zoning code or a plan development some sort of performance criteria so that as you either sell off portions or you lease portions of the site there's some guidelines there on not only the way the buildings might look and what materials they would have but picking up on the street connectivity and the trail connectivity because most times in conventional development you have a developer come in and they just look at their own site and they really don't connect to their neighbors so that would be a big component of the code would be requiring these again performance criteria so that one development has to connect to another um and i didn't point it out earlier but uh when we were looking at the preferred plan but you see little lines there especially in the in the purple areas and so there are just kind of notional ideas of how lots could start being partitioned off and and uh you know in the let's say two acre segments or one acre segments you might have a variety of sizes but we want to start thinking about designing uh streets and so that they're based on on real criteria of what a developer or building developer might be looking for and is there another slide or is that there's there's one more and i was going to take that one mike and this is the last slide everyone uh we just wanted to give you a quick rundown of of next steps excuse me i take it that's george speaking i'm sorry george radnovich again sorry mayor and uh george rodney site southwest so we're almost done with the planning uh we'll be finalizing the draft plan in the next month or so uh in may and june we'll be presenting the final plan uh to city council planning and zoning and obviously to the public for last comments and then we'll present the plan in final form for adoption in june july time frame um the the plan that we have right now is a final draft and uh we'll be we'll be working on the sections that we presented to you today over the next month and as we receive feedback from you both today and in the in the near future so with that we'll leave it up for discussion uh and uh comments questions and anything you might have for us okay thanks george um before we go to council on pnz can you go back a couple slides i just want to clarify a couple things please uh one more there you go right there oh no can you go back again there you go okay so on number four um the north side of lowman i think you have it designated as blm property so immediately to the left i guess when you're looking at it immediately west of that you know that used to be a landfill also were you aware of that we were okay so you feel that that item four could still be you i mean because that that now that side i have to admit versus the other side where what we call what the city cleaned up now that site is is really really really bad um there's a lot of stuff there that's why we didn't i don't think we cleaned it you know it's just it was just a lot and so but you feel that that's still buildable though it would have to be mitigated the landfill would have to be mitigated in order to do that mayor but yes it could be and the other side is as you know a lot more buildable and one of the past plans i believe it was the east loman plan designated that number four on the north as uh and i think they that you knew this when you designated it that way as a community garden and a uh desert landscape garden so it could be that the reason we saw a hotel on that site if uh if the market uh required it was because this hotel wherever it ends up would be close to the to the medical center and be there for people that might be there visiting loved ones and of course right right and then the second thing is and i don't know if larry or david can chime in on this but i seem to recall oh gosh at least 15 years or ago that there was a limitation on the number of stories i think it was 36 feet or three stories now that may be just applying to residential like an apartment complex but i thought it applied to both residential commercial because you you all would put three or four stories and so um probably to keep that commitment to to the residents because we may want to just stay with three but again that's council can always change it but it was implemented back in 2000 and 2003 2004 around that area and it was to protect obviously the beautiful view of the of the organs and so the council at that time thought that okay three stories was the maximum in fact there's a there's a green building on road runner parkway that's probably no more than three stories and i often wonder if that was the reason why they did it that's you know three stories okay that's all i wanted to say now i'm going to open up to members of the council and commission so it looks like we have councillor stork and then counselor basis foodie thank you mayor uh counselor stewie can go first if she would like okay counselor thank you councillor beta stubby thank you uh and thank you um to site southwest and civic plan um everybody for the great presentation um a couple of questions uh related mostly towards uh pedestrian and transportation and transportation one of the items that you were looking at was that of the bike lanes the walkability and i know that we have had a resolution for complete streets um and larry this might for you too does our coding now reflect those changes um which would go into the stuff that we have here or would we still need to be working on that type of coding and uh mayor and council uh major stevie larry nichols you know that we are at this time we are going through a zoning update uh with our consultant and it's uh interesting to know that we have the sea sloman plan developing as well as that review coming forward and i think the number of those items are going to be addressed concurrently we're chime in on this because uh he's been working with both of those both of these plans but dave what say thank you larry mayor and city councilors the the coding does not have specific requirements for complete streets that's a policy but what's unique about this particular property or a couple of points one it is owned by the city so as development goes forward you can um put requirements on how you'd like to see it and two it's in uh it's currently zoned plan unit development without basically a holding zone or open space so as you go forward and entitle what we call entitle this property you could incorporate those standards and have requirements as called out in the plan for pedestrian bicycle transit microtransit elements uh in your actual zoning or development standards for this property and that was david ware speaking thank you no problem thank you i appreciate that um i also wanted to know i like the idea of making sure if we do have any community centers those types of gathering spaces open if there's ability to have that middle the missing middle or if we're able to do any sort of affordable housing to have those kind of connected together so that um individuals are able to walk uh easily to those areas um especially if we're gonna have senior sites too um and the only last thing that i wanted to bring up and i just recall it from a different meeting we had um the existing community right um to the south i remember that there was some concerns about traffic flow um in areas i believe and so um i i really appreciate having some of the other neighborhoods for their place because i think that would have a higher traffic and so it seems to separate things out a bit more so i do um really like seeing that and that's all from me mayor thanks thank you okay counselor sword rial thank you mr mayor and thank you to southwest uh for the presentation and and um it looks like you've done a very good job um i think we can make this uh 20th 21st century city 23 21st century planning which is something i'm looking forward to having all these aspects such as storm water capture uh missing middle housing affordable housing in fact we should have a target of 20 of all the housing in this development being affordable housing um habitat presentation presentat preservation rather uh the act of transportation including tod orientated development um form based code i'm so glad to see that here too um i was looking for the connection uh for the existing neighborhoods the ones to the south uh for bike and and foot traffic and and i see there's some nice connections you have put in there um but also if i hope we can kind of squeeze in uh other neighborhoods to the north and to the um west or southwest of this development get a connection there somehow to get to this development um a couple of things that came to my mind that i wasn't mentioned in fact more than a couple um we talked about in the in the uh um public uh input uh uh that we held possibly having a pedestrian bridge to go across loman to the hospital and and the medical offices there um a pedestrian bridge i should say did i say that bridge i meant to say where um people wouldn't have to fight traffic to get across especially in cases where people might be in in wheelchairs or or or so forth um and then when you show the slide that had those on the hill uh showed those steps that were kind of uh contoured up the side of a hill brought to mind a street in san francisco san francisco called lombardi street i would think it'd be awfully cool if we could put a lombardi street in there on that hill um we could have it our own las cruces lombardi street and um but there is there is one more unique opportunity in this development that it would be like no other development uh at least not in las cruces maybe in a lot of places across the southwestern nation we could have this be a net zero community for all the buildings that are built there that's a net zero uh energy community um and so just to give you an idea what i'm talking about here uh a net zero home for example is a home that creates all the energy it uses in short it means there is no electric bill the net zero home means that when you take the amount of energy a home creates then subtract the amount of energy the home uses it equals zero um and we could make this whole community a net zero community where we would not be putting any greenhouse gases into the air in this community um because we want houses that are all wired for total electric use we want them to have uh wired for uh solar pv uh installed on the top of the buildings or anywhere else that it can be and we want all the uh buildings to have outlets for electric vehicles um and so i think this is what one thing that would be quite unique and i would encourage this the the council and the staff and and the mayor here to uh support a net zero community um one last thing uh you have on the map there uh a street called foothills drive um don't we already have a foothills drive in this city question for our staff yes we do okay staff that that was council that was counselor florida's right oh no that voice just sounds like me it's not really mayor i i'm kind of curious in how the name foothills drive got put in there mayor and city council this is david weir again that's a remnant the old foothills drive used to go through this property out to the another landfill site and so all the maps still as the ride away from foothills but that has that right of way has been redirected and it actually passes heads north of lowman and comes out on roadrunner parkway so as we we'll correct that as um the the plan is updated and finalized okay okay i assumed you would i just had to bring it out so we all know getting back to the net zero uh buildings you can make net zero buildings even on affordable housing uh when i was visiting uh austin texas for a national league of cities convention we were taken to a net zero development uh not a development but a small i guess there was three or four units that had i think two they were like duplexes and they were all net zero and they're all affordable housing and uh so it can be done and so therefore i'm encouraging our council to support a uh net zero community okay mayor if that's all for right now maybe more later okay thank you counselor ben cuomo thank you mayor and thanks everyone um it was great to see the presentation again they were at our housing prc um either last month or the month before zoom time is weird i'm not sure um but i did just have a couple questions i'm curious in terms of the conversation we just had yesterday um at our work session with the water impact fees and that changing and the split being 50 50. that obviously will impact this development right um is there any room potential um waivers particularly for the affordable housing um development that could go here that um you know could be an incentive for developers to to want to you know build more of those affordable housing units more of those missing middle units you know counselor let me just kind of chime in on this one so one of the things that kind of been exploring is if we were to enter into a public private partnership with a developer and then and obviously one of the things the developer does is they have to put in the infrastructure you know the sewer system the water system all the different lines and then after and then after they get it all done um they give it to the city but they first pay for it up front so there's we what we may want to look at is we put in that infrastructure the city that's our contribution in return for them to provide so much affordable housing because that's that much less money that they're gonna have to put in and so that may be a way to to to do this and then they have to provide so much affordable housing because we've we've put in the infrastructure and then um i can't tell you how many times i get from the the deans of the university or professors of engineering school that they want to use their engineers to help do real life examples and so we might be able to use them as well um in in conjunction with our engineers there at the city to help install this so they can get real life experience and so we may be able to keep the cost down on that as well does that yeah yeah great ideas mayor i think for i mean i think this project can be very visionary and it can be very collaborative in terms of like really getting it done in the way that we hope it gets done and so i think those are great ideas i don't know if um i heard someone before i started speaking is there another question yeah and then my last question is um i don't know if natalie is on or even our pio but i think it's really important that we start thinking now in terms of um just like messaging strategies i think that there's a lot of misinformation i think that there's a lot of misunderstanding about affordable housing and those kinds of projects from uh a big part of our community i'm afraid that particularly in this area that might come up and and folks you know pushing against this kind of development here and so i think it's important that we start thinking about messaging strategies that um you know really lift up the need for this that really lifts up how thoughtful this process is and and why you know why affordable um housing developments are necessary and so i've been talking to natalie and not having prc about this for a while but i i just want to make sure and i don't know if southwest consultants if you all provide any of those kinds of things um i just think it's an important piece to consider for the future no uh telstra can you bring up a good point and i think maybe it will change the name of it from necessarily affordable housing to just make mixed uh income housing uh and and i want to use the example of um of southwest airlines and those free tickets you know a long time ago i used to get some free tickets and and then you know there are people who when you go on on the flight there's going to be some that pay full price there's going to be some who got great discounts and some are for free you know because they they have these coupons but the plane is a brand new plane and that basically when if i circle back to what i was saying about that public-private partnership these are beautiful uh structures some will pay the regular price and some are going to pay a very discounted price because that developer is that's the agreement that they'll get to take with the city if we provide this type of infrastructure i mean you're talking hundreds of thousands of dollars that they won't have to pay and in return the bottom line they're going to be looking at the bottom line you know you know when they build out a project they want a bottom line but if we if we provide this then their bottom line goes up and then how it comes down so it comes back to where they first started is that's how they provide certain housing at certain income levels but you're not going to know because you know the outside's going to be great i mean everything's going to be good and it's just going to be certain people are going to get it a little bit cheaper and then that's it and i think that's really the way to go you know as a kid growing up here there was a place where near lynn middle school that you knew that was that was an area and that's what we want to get away from you know you just want to be able to go to an area that you don't know who who lives there and how much they pay for rent or you know i think that's what you're getting at and and mayor and council we did consider uh mixed affordability in in the housing and we've heard that repeatedly from the public uh and from council and planning and zoning and uh that that is part of the planning effort that we've gone through and it also is included in the market study they identified it as an important need as well when rcl code did the market study for us so we we do have it planned in uh as uh as mixed use housing as the mayor said so i just wanted to assure you of that thank you and so that was that was george talking about i'm sorry yes george ratner thanks mayor thank you no it's okay and and um yes i think these so this is really great i think my point is more in terms of how are we communicating and messaging this to the community so that it's um so that we're getting rid of some of those you know old school tropes and myths about what affordable housing is i think that's a really good point counselor thank you i think we have some uh airline props at our movie studio uh maybe you guys can do a movie and you won't know who pays what and that's how you kind of translate it uh before i get to um commissioner thomas we have larry nichols has a as his hand up we don't have a studio anymore okay thank you mayor larry nichols for the record larry nichols uh and captain como i i would like to answer a couple of your uh comments uh there and you know we have been really heavily engaged in talking about affordable housing particularly the last couple of years and one of the challenges that i presented to site southwest when we first initiated this project was give us a give us a master plan that offers a point of difference let's not repeat everything that maybe has been done before because it didn't really address the uh instead of affordable housing i think the mayor had a very good point when he used the term uh mixed income housing because that's really what we need to head towards uh yes uh natalie green with the affordable housing component that she has in the uh now economic development department but has in the you know the funding availability that that's one thing uh mentioned earlier is there some way we could wave i have to be perfectly candid with you we don't have a lot of ability to wave fees but we can't find ways of of deferring them or or finding a different alternative means of methods of addressing them and so i think that's where we could really spend our effort but uh the idea of having a uh development like this that has a point of difference and maybe the point of difference is what councilor sorg mentioned maybe we have a means of uh our mixed income housing in reduction in utility bills you know it's not only uh affordable uh housing or uh multiple uh levels of income housing the initial cost it's the operation costs as well so maybe we concentrate on that but i think there's uh this plan this master plan is visionary you know uh when the mayor first brought this uh parson land to uh to us and said let's do something with this uh i got calls from all kinds of developers and and real estate agents and and folks saying this is a very attractive parcel of land for a development let's do it right but also let's make it unique the idea of mixing housing types and uh availability of of income housing types i think that's our point of difference with this i i think we really have an opportunity there and uh i know that the consultant is striving for that the community development department is striving for that i think i think we have an opportunity here thank you very much thanks larry councillor bin como was that it yeah before i get to commissioner thomas i just want to take a quick moment to and i know they're not listening but uh former albuquerque mayor r.j berry and um i call him the dean of the developers uh eddie bins it wasn't for the fact that eddie didn't was willing to sell us some land for the veterans park and mayor r.g berry was able to do a little swap and then he threw this land in here which we essentially paid like half a million dollars for um and and i have to tell you that land went in 1999 for ten dollars a square foot there's 110 acres that puts us at over 50 million dollars in value for you know for a fraction of that so just wanted to send those those two gentlemen thanks so commissioner sharon thomas you have a question yes um thank you mayor this is sharon thomas for the record um so i'm also concerned about the affordable housing i don't know if you can go back to that slide but it looks on the graphics like the missing middle is over on one part and the single family is someplace else and um can we not have uh missing some missing middle integrated with the single family i mean i've seen that in other places um and i don't see anything actually about affordable housing i i think um what um councillor sorg said you know a percentage that gets integrated across the area i mean i really like as the mayor's talking about to see the missing middle and the affordable to be spread out across the the whole development so that you can't as he said say oh that part over there is where those people live um i'm i'm not really seeing that am i missing something here or i might be able to answer that this is michael houston uh again um so a couple of things one uh as jay mentioned even in that yellow area we're proposing that multiple units be permitted within a single lot but we are suggesting that the scale of those buildings still look more like a detached structure of maybe two stories maximum but it could still be a duplex uh triplex it's still basically a missing middle typology but we're um showing that the scale of it is going to be more compatible with the neighborhood to the to the south so and even though there's a difference between the yellow area and the the orange those things could be in the in a more detailed plan a more nuanced difference so there's going to be more interplay between the two as to how you implement that i think that would come in when you get into the zoning aspect if you do a form based code or or a plan development and you establish those performance criteria that could be one of the components of the performance criteria that you have right now we're focusing more on the open space and the street network and these transitions but that's kind of an element of the of the performance criteria and in the best case scenario you would have a mix you'd have market rate next to uh affordable housing and you would really wouldn't know the difference that was the whole idea of the the pedestrian neighborhood and another thing i was going to mention about the pedestrian neighborhood since we were looking at that slide that had the four housing types is that uh you know that's a concept that we kind of invented for this project and we've taken it inspiration from other projects but we haven't done this exact idea but we do think that this concept could be tried out maybe in other elements in other locations in the city so if you have land that's deer downtown or or within the city limits that you want to do a pilot project and and try out this housing type uh you know might be a good way to start before you commit to doing a larger area hope i just wanted to add that uh i think you're right we haven't shown on any of this lives i'm sorry this is george radnovich at site southwest thank you mayor that'll be the last time you have to prompt me i'm going to start finding you a dollar it's happened before um commissioner thomas i think you're right we haven't posted on any of our drawings uh for the presentation however we have included it in the report um a mixed income or an affordable housing component and i think i think we really need to add that to the uh to the presentation uh and to the drawings to make sure that it's covered so thank you for pointing that out yeah i think that's what i would ask if going forward if if you could be a little more specific about some of those ideas because i that's what i hear people saying they they want to see this mixed and not be able to tell what's the affordable and what's that and you know i'm a fan of the holiday development in boulder because my sister-in-law's sister lives there so i'm familiar with that development and you really really cannot tell even though 30 of it is affordable housing you can't pick it out and i hope we can do that in this also i didn't hear anything about um high-speed internet now that's all going to be available here right we we didn't get to that level of detail in in the plan at this point but high-speed internet would be uh would be available i believe uh we'll have to check that with uh uh with our city partners uh and um we can we can definitely include that in the plan as well it's part of all planning at this point that would be great um you know we just have more even though we might be working our way out of this dilemma with covet you know we have more and more people working remotely and they're going to probably continue to do so a lot of them so we want to make sure that we're providing that possibility so thank you those are my questions and thank you for your answers yeah commissioner just a couple things if i remember correctly there is high-speed internet because as you recall the hospitals across the street and they needed that for their you know to be able to download the things that they do for medical x-rays and such and then the second thing is um and i and i i would think that some of our people on the on the on the team on site southwest is familiar with the sawmill district there in albuquerque and it's possible that we may be able to incorporate on some of that land uh some of the same principles so that it it so that they can actually own their own home there at a relatively lower rate and then but then also prevent them from selling it at some huge profit so that they just they get a modest profit if they need to sell it and then they give it to someone you know they're able to sell to someone else so we might be able to incorporate something like that but i think overall the the whole plan it looks great but um and then of course that's what we're doing here today is just kind of giving our input uh back and forth okay so we've got commissioner vasquez and then um i'm excuse me counselor vasquez and then commissioner gordon's councilor thank you so much thank you mayor um thank you to my colleagues for their thoughtful comments and questions as well as yours mayor and i'm excited to see uh how fast a conceptual design and project can come together when there's some real motivation to do so right i think for me this has been one of the shortest planning and design faces of this type of development since i've been here in the city and rightfully so um you know it's a great place to develop and you know mayor i agree with you on the uh on the public private partnership opportunities i think we want to maximize the amount of drt that we can get out of this property considering um the investment that we that we just really hit the lottery on uh much credit to you as well for for that foresight to get this this piece of land here um so i think you know taking off of perhaps on a much smaller scale what we've done with the amador what we were thinking about doing with the dona ana county um courthouse uh you know this might be on a much larger scale but um you know i think we should definitely pursue that option as much as we can and and we retain uh you know a lot of the control obviously of what happens there if we do that so i want to say i support that um in terms of in terms of the affordable housing piece of things here um i yeah i mean i say i would say that you know the majority of our population in las cruces fits into the category of uh being someone who needs affordable housing and so i just want us to remind ourselves of that you know in terms of our perhaps our per capita household income oftentimes the folks that are the most vocal against affordable housing projects um they may be the most vocal but they they are in the minority and so we want to make sure that i think we are serving the majority of our residents um as much as we can in these types of developments and giving folks access um to to in an affordable way have livable walkable bikeable healthy communities is is going to make us stand out from from other communities you know i've seen a little bit of the metro verde neighborhood certainly sonoma ranch and how that's been built out in its different phases and some of those amenities that those folks have out there are terrific the walking paths the gyms the big parks um you know that concept that we saw uh i think out in metro verde for that almost like a mini downtown that their the developer wants to build out there are terrific um and so i want to make sure those same amenities and that same quality of life is available to folks of different incomes and so i think this would be a project that would allow us to do that so i fully support the affordable housing component of this um we've done it before you know i think if you look at um if you look at like south tel shore from you know from really from university um up to lowman and and if you look at the west side of tel shore uh you have a mix of i mean you have yeah 700 800 000 houses with you know 600 uh dollar co a month condos on the same street uh on many of those streets and folks coexist happily and folks are respectful of each other and it's a beautiful vibrant neighborhood um part of my district is in there um right there to the to the um uh i'm sorry to the east of missouri uh sorry i said west but really both sides but on the east side of loman and so it is possible it is possible and i think we can do it here as well and we should do it and so uh fully support that um and then lastly uh yeah i think this is a thoughtful process inside southwest i think has done a great job for us as as they have in the past on other city contracts of both engaging our community and engaging public and soliciting public input in a way that i think is meaningful that is easy to digest and that gives me confidence in moving forward with this project lastly to guilt to counselor stork's comment uh i i would say yes let's promote as much of sustainable energy production and net zero uh uses we can especially if we do um you know retain uh land ownership status uh in this process but certainly through the zoning process as well uh but i'd say also let's not let that be the the enemy uh let's not let the perfect be the enemy of the good right because i think um we want to make sure those those those homes for people are at an affordable rate that we're able to actually attract folks so so maybe there's a good happy medium in terms of led certification and other types of requirements that we may include that may be less restrictive than entirely a net zero community but also get us to where we want to be so thank you mayor those are my my comments thank you uh counselor uh commissioner gordon commissioner gordon that sounds like from batman commissioner this is this is harvey gordon that's what they said the first night that i sat on the plane as owning commission the chairman said maybe we should send up the bat signal and it's just been with me ever since i guess um i i just like to repeat once i've said this before i just think another good point commissioner did i have you state your name i'm sorry yes i did i said harvey gordon oh okay sorry about it i'm thinking about batman oh you're muted okay i had repeated this once before about another access road i still like the idea of having an access road onto lowman if you look at the word on this uh display that we have here the word east lawman and just a little bit to the right of it you'll see that there have been two developments of some real real business property that have been put on on the south side of lowman and in between these two are a piece of property that's been abandoned now for oh many many years you can just see some steel girders that are there it might be a good idea it's somebody to think about perhaps buying that piece of property and bringing an access road down from the south side where the white is onto onto loma just down the hill it just will give you another access onto loma without having to summon it go all the way around if you could draw a line you put a circle there just bring that up to that little green spot and you can see what i'm talking about right there bring a line down there that's that's one thought i've had and it's just something that i would like to see and perhaps maybe in the future if it's a good idea or could be done and the other thing as far as affordable housing i think the one word that people have avoided saying today is stigma and i don't like to use that word but a lot of people think of it in that terms but i will let that rest but my question is if you look at the this whole parcel that we're talking about here this whole roman plan if you look at the big there are two large parcels of land to the uh to the west and to the north one to the west southwest of of lorman which would border alongside boulevard you see the big piece of property i'm talking about that's it there are drawn in here some roadways is that just for a concept or is that is that the way it has to be that's number one number two on the other side of the street on the corner of roman and sonoma ranch boulevard there's another large piece of property and i understand at one time there was some interest there in putting up a assisted living facility but i think that idea has fallen through but i like these two pieces of property that would be thought of as an anchor to a like to a mall i think what could happen here i think all that property is privately owned if somebody comes in and wants to develop that how they develop that they drive what everybody else is thinking about doing on this east roman project i don't know if there is any interest there now but eventually i'm sure there will be that piece of property that very large piece could very well go to somebody like trader joe's possibly even a costco on the other side and maybe a little smaller i don't know what they do there but to me that's going to be a very very important thing to happen to this project what's going to go there and i don't know if there has been anything said or what it actually means with those lines drawn for roads but you can see there's an access road coming out of the project that will hook onto one of those uh so i don't know exactly what it is so it's just a thought of mine i'd like maybe somebody could tell me if this is just a concept or this has to be what it's going to be when that land is developed this is george radnovich with scythe southwest mayor uh commissioner um commissioner gordon um we didn't do uh um the charge for our for our work was really to develop plans for that primarily city-owned portion of the property and not so much the privately owned areas that's why we haven't touched in great detail that area we do have some concepts that we developed early on in the project that we could take a little bit further for that area as you know it is privately owned uh and it's the only privately owned uh strip between sonoma ranch and loman and south to uh canyon point so um uh we just we just didn't have that in our in our scope and and hadn't uh hadn't done much with that area but we did want to show how it could uh it could uh integrate into the planning that we were doing on the site that we did have charged for well there's harvey gordon again i understand what you're saying but it's just well i'm looking at this and just everything goes through my mind as what eventually could be there i think what you've developed is a wonderful plan i think i i like the work you've done i want to thank you very much for what you've done but uh just a couple of thoughts especially that i'm really concerned about that access road i would like to see that down there it would make it a lot easier for people to get out of the middle of that old big parcel you get down to lowman very good comments and uh and this is george radnovich again and and thank you commissioner thank you uh let's see who's next is um counselor flores uh thank you mayor and thank you uh danny mike george mario and jay it's nice to see you again i met all of you i think it was in december yes december and that was a very successful meeting and we had a pretty good out turnout it was right i think right well it was right between thanksgiving and christmas it was during the holidays um it was close to christmas i believe um but at any rate i want to thank you once again and and george it's always delightful to see the work that you do outside southwest i first met you i think it was last summer late spring when you presented uh the plan for the park at the airport excuses airport so again thank you for your fantastic work and i want to say that um jay um for all of for everyone who's concerned about the housing issue uh jay if i recall correctly in her presentation last december made it very clear that uh there would be different kinds of housing and that it wouldn't be something that would be a glaring difference in so far as the plan the design goes and of course it would be our job to make sure that we get a builder that has the design and excuse me the architectural features uh if you will i'm not an architect um that would definitely uh integrate all sorts of uh housing and i i like to think in terms of attainable housing and i think that uh whether it's rented or or purchased and so i'm very happy mr mayor that you mentioned that perhaps it would be a mixed what did you say mixed income and um and or somebody's puppy is happier than mine it's probably sharon's little dog um at any rate um i just want to thank you and also um wanted to uh i wanted to bring something up and now i totally totally um yeah i just wanted to mention that jay did bring up um the possibilities of of uh our really you know the ball is going to be in our you know the ball will be um in our you know on on in our court we'll be able to determine um how we want those designs and um and then of course natalie green i hope will be working closely all along to assure that um these this housing is definitely falls within the parameters of hud uh for quote affordable unquote housing and then um have other designs or uh housing units that are really viable and attainable for for those who would like to live there oh i know my question uh might or um well any of you but i think i think george always opens up so i think i should address my question to george um so have you were you involved in the um designs and and that you showed us um in colorado savannah tucson monticello and el paso and then cul-de-sac and tempe and holiday in boulder were you did you design that with was psych southwest uh the designer uh thank you for the uh good words this is george radnovich with site southwest uh councillor flores and uh we were not the designers of cul-de-sac or savannah um or the monticello montezio development in el paso we did work with that developer in el paso on that on that project uh uh peripherally uh because we were working on what was going to be called aldea el paso that uh uh didn't happen or hasn't happened yet anyway um but uh i would like jay if you're uh if you're willing i'd like you to uh talk to that idea of uh mixed income uh if you if you could speaking jay narina um again i think uh um one of the things we want to make sure is that the housing types themselves provide the diversity for different uh income types uh i think the idea of having the modules where you can go from a 900 square foot to a 2 000 square foot it gives you a range a lot of times the reason why housing becomes expensive and uh and unaffordable is the size of the lot and so once we start kind of working on eliminating some of those barriers that increase the price of housing we want a market to deliver a more affordable product organically and then the city participating in some of the infrastructure kind of reducing the cost from developer to kind of also provide that that balance of housing the problem with a lot of times with state requirements for affordable housing that it has to meet a certain threshold 80 60 percent of uh the median income uh becomes that they have standards for parking and it kind of limits the city's ability to be flexible and thinking outside the box and doing a pilot project similar to the cul-de-sac development that maybe it's it's you know a lot of times you end up with 200 units that are you know 70 percent affordable and it looks like a suburban apartment uh complex because that's what the that's what some of these developers know from a formula standpoint they know what works and how they make money uh using hud and and the state uh um you know affordable housing uh programs so i would just kind of uh make sure that um you know the the vision for this is is allowing for a range of duplex town homes um of granny flats uh kind of the range that not just hits just one uh segment of the market but really um for people nurses and people working in in the hospital industry and looking for maybe students and um other uh folks who have different needs in their depending on their life cycle where they are in their life cycle thank you jay that's what you um covered in december and that was very well received if i recall i do recall it was very well received thank you again jay and thank you okay uh mayor pro tem mayor pro tem gandera thank you mayor sorry i was having problems with my button there um yeah thank you so much southwest for your presentation um as i was listening to it i was thinking um a few things being a model um sort of a you know being able to do innovative things in this in this um and with this area um i love the the three or four i think you mentioned um themes the population health the traditional neighbors conservation neighborhoods um you know just building on the existing infrastructure i do want to make note that i'm very much um for um at least 20 percent of that being affordable housing and i think we're trying to move away from using that term and utilizing the mixed right amount or mis income housing would be really important um i've seen um the the renderings for the el paso uh you know the the the um thing you mentioned for with el paso and had um conversations with one of the engineers or designers i don't know what you call them but um it really was it interesting and and i like to move into something like that and i'm i'm really interested in um mayor's um great ideas mayor about the private public partnerships and building the infrastructure i i you know to lower the cost i think that's something that we should really consider and mayor i'm not sure what your thoughts are around that would we have simply a a different work session to speak specifically on on what that might look like or you work with staff to um you know get some pricing and and whatnot um related to that as we incorporate sort of the plans moving forward now let me reach out to the dean of engineering school because um yeah they've asked if there's projects that their students can do you know that's what they do i mean they're they work on some some civil engineers some electrical engineers yeah it'd be because i haven't after you finished i was going to throw one more thing in there that's why i threw it in electrical engineers but the civil engineers for sure that they can start knowing how to develop the sewer systems and the and the uh water they know everything i think it'd be great right and you know mayor um gil and i excuse me counselor sorghum and i participated in in a session with arrowhead and some of the things that the engineering department are doing you know not just on the things that you've just mentioned but the mass development moving forward right um i'm thinking about solar with dacc i mean i just think the ideas are endless um and and so i i want to just make sure that that doesn't get lost um i think it's it's really important um and then i i'm um i've been hearing the form-based codes and the performance um criteria and i think and i'm sorry if if this has already been explained i got kicked off and i had to quickly get back on um and maybe larry nichols talked about this now did you say that we're re i know we're revamping our zoning but are those areas that you're looking at as well and would they be helpful in in this with this particular um scenario larry yes uh mayor and counselor gandera larry nichols for the record uh yes i did refer to that earlier in in today's presentation and the uh the update of the zoning code uh does have the uh uh a uh look at the design standards and i think that's what you're referring to be part of that update and review and upgrade it hasn't been it hasn't been visited since 2001 yeah we've had a lot of changes come about and how we do things since then the design standards are a part of that review so that so i'm thinking that that would be helpful and would when they mention um very interested in hearing more about the parking in the back rather than in the front you know some of those things that i think you know we just don't really see in our community right and and something we definitely want to consider um i think um especially in those areas if we want it to be pedestrian and bike friendly if we were wanting for people to you know get out into the the natural wonders um i i think all that would be really important and to construct this duvet's concern you know we just heard a uh an issue with um traffic and and and just above that area that she mentioned um and and so all that would be um i think an important thing to consider yes ma'am mayor and councilor gandra larry nichols for the record those are and i i think uh counselor um sorg and chairman thomas of dnc chairman thomas well they're disciples of new urbanism and this plan incorporates a lot of those concepts and ideas yeah i think you know the building set to the street parking behind you know those type of things we got to take advantage of those i mean we we know that there are improvements on what we have done in the past the plan talks about that yeah so larry when you look at this some of that and we're looking at affordable housing um or that mix income housing if you will i'll get used to saying it the other way the mixed income housing um and and you're looking at some of the limitations or like i don't know i would assume there's federal state guidelines specific to that um or or is there would we have is there i guess that's my question is is those things we have to consider moving forward when we are doing mixed income housing mayor and counselor gandra we do have to consider those there are very specific guidelines on how those things are developed uh but i believe that we have the capacity to to take those into consideration and begin to implement them into our new our new developments you know the east loman is is one of them uh we have other uh projects that are are being spoken about you know we're talking about the uh el paseo salona corridor uh it's going to and i think miss green talked about that this morning about a project coming up in in that area so you know today's presentation is on the east loma but we do have city-wide projects that we would should begin to incorporate the thinking that you have just expressed there and uh we're we're keeping that we're ever mindful of that we're going to keep that okay cool thank you larry i appreciate that um and then lastly um mayor you made mention about the about the landfill in that area can someone point out where that would be and not sure that we've made it done the work there no we haven't we haven't and then i can point it out yeah uh this is george radnovich at site southwest uh counselor and hi hi counselor gundera hi how are you good how are you doing great good we we just uh danny just circled that area that hasn't been mitigated yet okay and and i'm assuming that we have definitely have to take that into consideration and that and the money and in order to to do that so i would i would hope that staff would have i don't know if delilah or mayor you know what how many acres that is and what the price would be to mitigate that and in terms of of um kind of the plans and how it what will come first if this is something that we should be considering now rather than later yeah well mayor pro tem that's currently owned by the blm uh-huh and and it probably would be i don't you know see the other land was is is the cities right right oh so that is something there that we knew that we could uh we get our return on investment on but blm land uh unless they gave it to us and you know the goodness of their heart i don't know you know so i mean i don't know if that's that's just the projected area yeah i don't know if that's something there that i bet you i would imagine it would probably cost at least a million dollars and maybe a little bit more to clean up yeah because it's very concentrated there and there's a lot of that's why if residents are driving up there and the sun catches it just right you see all these little sparkles that's glass interesting yeah it's something that may be stopping and and um mr peeley should have conversations with our our our folks there at blm and see what if there's an appetite right for doing something in terms of of giving it or selling it whatever that whatever that would look like and then george you mentioned the foothills area and and and um that it's going to require more study and you i thought you said something like sooner rather than later did you say that and and and what are the plans related to that in terms of studying it would staff have to go back to the drawing board and contract with you all or within procurement code um thank you counselor this is george radnovich and thank you mayor um david did you want to broach that subject i i can mayor and city council this is david weir community development um i think a lot of the questions you are asking about really slide into the next steps and implementation of the plan once it's uh developed so once we get a consensus and we go forward with this development plan for the area then the city will have to make a decision on how they're going to approach developing that property is it something that the city is going to do in-house themselves in contract with the different engineers is it something where we're going to put together a proposal for requests for information or request for qualifications to develop that are we going to market it for sale for one or multiple developers to put a team together and and build the plan um so that will be the next decision point towards uh implementation but first things need to be done is to reach a consensus on this plan as that this is the land use mix this is the transportation network these are the housing mix elements that that you want to see take place and then i said there'll be another decision point uh with implementation so if i was unclear on anything uh please i'd i'd be happy to respond or answer any questions you have no no no i i just want to i'd like to just hear sort of all the options or um i think you were you were pretty clear on that um and sometimes we want we get ahead of ourselves so i i want i i think the way this was presented is really exciting um this could definitely be where we can you know put a lot of of creativity in the way in which we do that and and some of the ideas already put forth are are are you know from mayor and and other city councilors is is what i would agree and i definitely agree with commissioner thomas that we want to not single out the mixed income housing that it it should be evenly distributed right throughout um and i did hear council vasquez make mention of you know the townhouses and if you know mixed in with some very large and higher income um homes and and then and i and i think those are things that that um that are really important to me and again that um and i think commissioner um gordon did have a great um suggestion about that that particular piece of property that has been vacant for so many years and looking at the opportunity of an exit entry way right out of the area i i really like that idea it makes sense to me um and then um i want to put a pitch in for counselor florida she didn't make mention it but if when we have affordable housing committee housing prc meeting she makes mention of this quite a bit and this is about um you know the city sort of leasing land or or you know the lots if you will and buying and people putting property their homes or whatever right there um i think here's a great opportunity that we might you know maybe model and some of that um and and i again i think this property here this is is a way is a is a great opportunity to to put in a lot of concepts that we've been talking about at least since i've been here and longer vermeer and gill so um i think this is again um a great great um concepts and thank you georgian staff sites thanks mayor thank you uh before i get to counselor store i have a quick question so on the on the green space that's um um you know i guess where paseo de onyate is now that's that high heel correct that is actually a a low point um in the uh drive from uh loehmann down to uh canyon point uh before it before it crosses the uh the um uh uh the the arroyo um there's a there's a high point as you go from there towards the uh north and uh east and then there's a high point i'm sorry i guess i didn't mean that that is uh the next street uh i guess or that one right there all that green that green area no no no no no foothills right right here right here yep yeah that's that's the high area correct about i'm sorry mayor the highest point on the site george radnovich with site southwest uh is that roundabout uh like uh point in the middle right there yep okay but but i'll talk about that green area so what i was trying to get at is uh if there was a way to incorporate at the time you guys were doing this it hadn't been passed yet as law but now there's um an opportunity for community solar and you know you want to put it out of the way and what better place than is this because it's so high up there and we're not gonna we're not gonna you know reduce it but if we could kind of get it to the point where we build it inside that that area it's out of the way and then we can help uh lower um the electric bills to the residents 20 30 percent and that just makes it that much more attractive especially again going back to the mixed income that just adds more affordability to them so yeah okay so that was one thing the second thing is at the very in the royal area the the buffer um those little small white lines those are are those walking trails they are oh perfect wow that's great that's that's excellent and then the last thing and i see adrienne here i don't i think she's probably covering for um for delilah is during the excavation uh adrienne were you aware did you guys come across anything i received an email from a professor about biology professor i think from the university uh wanting to know if uh or or thinks that there may be some prehistoric sites there or bones there and i know we can get with them after once we start doing the excavation but were you aware of anything that they discovered anything while they were cleaning out those particular areas that's adrian because i didn't see delilah on the on the call that she's there but adrian are you there i thought i saw you well maybe i didn't okay well okay who's uh who's over the utilities this is george radovich i don't see her on the uh list when they were cleaning up i mean did anyone come across anything um anyone saying you know did utilities tell you give you any reports of any bones that you know prehistoric anything there um if i wasn't aware of any but that doesn't mean that there wasn't there so we'll get with that professor and and he had asked if if when we start doing more excavation if they can just be on site in case they're you know they come across something that could be kind of interesting okay that's that's all i had uh counselor sword yes thank you mayor um yeah utilities isn't in this meeting today i noticed all the people there i didn't see anybody representing utilities actually actually this is flores keller flores uh adrian whitmer was on um earlier in the meeting yeah okay fairness to adrian in that department well i just wanted to emphasize again um to council vasquez in particular i hope he's listening carefully here uh the net zero uh buildings uh can be built in an affordable or a low-income building uh it's done all the way across the southwest from austin to phoenix and and into the california um so there's many different examples of that so we don't have to be afraid uh when you put all electric homes in that they will be priced out of uh for low income or mixed income housing um the key to a zero building of course is energy efficiency you've got to build these buildings so that they uh don't lose heat in the wintertime and they don't bring heat in in the summertime that uh insulation and efficiency is a key to make a net zero building work of any kind whether it be housing or not but so casa vasquez just imagine as larry nichols was saying um you're living in a home and the only utility you have to pay is your water waste water and trash you have no natural gas uh bill and you have no electric bill uh so this makes it quite attractive to low income any income people in fact so um i emphasize again we could make this whole project everything in here net zero buildings whether it be commercial buildings or homes apartment buildings what have you it can be done and just imagine uh what uh that will mean to the city of las cruces and excellent example for other developments all the way across the city and of course it lines itself with our our planning for uh phasing out of natural gas um and so this is perfect for us absolutely perfect um there is one part of this map here the uh street uh is it el paseo no el dor uh unate uh that street that goes to that neighborhood to the south just to the west of that there was some trash in that part of the ground there too i don't know how much trash something tells me it's not as bad as it was on the east side of that street but anyway that's something to keep in mind for the future um so that area was cleaned up counselor the only area that that isn't ours is that little blue area i think that's blm still where it says transit according to the utilities department no it was not it was potentially thinking of putting a park in there in which we didn't have to clean it up then in that case well maybe that's the part that's blm because there's some blm land still out there well yeah the blm is on the north side of east loman that's definitely blm but then the south side we we have that that's part of the whole purchase from albuquerque i think that's still blm right there where that little roundabout i'm pretty sure but this is true this is michael michael houston i think i can clarify that dashed line there represents what we understand that is blm property okay um and you see we're looking long term at maybe you acquire that and you put the two properties together and develop it but the dashed line is just to remind us that those are the two different areas anyway all i wanted to point out it was some trash in that part land two at one point and unless they changed their mind and went ahead and cleaned that up without us looking uh this is george radnovich at site southwest uh uh uh councillor sorg we uh we did and mayor um we did uh map actually the area that was mitigated as part of our planning and all of it uh so far anyway is uh east of the um of paseo de oniate yeah okay thank you thank you um i mentioned the pedestrian bridge i suppose that's getting a little ahead of ourselves here that's something we can always put in later i suppose you know what i just i just realized something uh counselor uh blm falls under the department of interior and guess who's in charge of the department yes very good so she's not a problem maybe i'll email her and uh okay okay send her an email and ask her if we can just have the land to have you darn right yeah i'll do something housing and lastly um just thinking out of the box completely here let's see if we can't put uh since this is a big hill we're talking about put a waterfall in like i have behind me right here that would be cool i would really set the whole property off from everything else i thank you mayor that's all i have okay well that would be counselor that's a great idea but that would be facing lowmen okay so somewhere yeah that would be actually that would be real nice okay well i think that answers all the questions um unless you know i'm assuming that all of you forgot to put your hand down unless you guys want another round of questions uh george ratner mature mayor i think uh that commissioner thomas has had her hand up for a while since the first time she spoke uh commissioner mike am i correct there i think she just took no i didn't i just didn't put my hand down okay but but i i do want to say i'm i'm just so pleased with the planning you've come up here it's something we've talked about for so long and we've been so anxious to get something on the ground so people can see what it looks like so thank you thank you very much and i understand that adrian thank you commissioner i understand adrian whitmer is on the phone adrian if you're there the question was i received an email from a i believe a biology professor and thought that they want to know if we had discovered any um artifacts when when they were cleaning up the area and if not if they could still have a chance to when we do further dirt work if they could kind of be available to just check out things it would be called mr mayor they would survey it yeah adrian are you there okay so she's not there so i'm just talking to oh there there you are go ahead adrienne hi there um so um i'm just having some technical difficulties so could you just repeat the last question i received an email from a professor at the university want to know if we discovered any artifacts while when when we were when the you when your department was cleaning up the the the area for you know when they're remediating the area and if not uh whether or not that they could still have a chance to look at uh further dirt or you know whenever they do more movement of dirt and by that time it probably will be turned over to whoever we in charge the development with but but did you come across were you aware of any artifacts that they came across while they were cleaning up the old landfill um no um i don't believe so because usually if you run into artifacts then you have to stop work and the new mexico historical society has to come down and take a look at it but if you will forward that email to us then what we can do is make sure that they're in the loop sounds good i appreciate it thank you absolutely you're welcome thank you okay so george does this pretty much conclude today's presentation it does it does mayor uh george radnovich slight southwest uh and uh happy to answer any other questions or uh provide any other information that you need uh this was a really great session i want to thank everybody for participating and uh for giving us some great comments and uh a great direction and uh i think we're right on track uh we will look forward to also getting any public comments for those of the public who are on the call and who might have their comments as well and i thank uh the mayor and and all of you uh counselors and commissioners thank you councillor flores and gandra and and everyone that we've and uh councillor sarg and everyone that has spoken to us yeah looks like mayor pro tem raised your hand i did mayor just um lastly is your website still active for this particular uh george radnovich with site southwest mayor uh counselors yes it is it's it's still uh still the same same location yep okay can you um repeat the website sure thing this is danny wilson site southwest um i was actually just going to jump to my last slide here um i plan to link to this recording once it's post or once we have it available on youtube uh with an update on the project website and even though the survey is closed um it will remain active as we publish the draft final plan once uh community development has had a chance to review it and uh planishloman.com is that website [Music] thank you what was that what was that danny i didn't quite hear that sure thing danny wilson it is plan eastlowmen.com oh thank you oh what all one word uh councillor flores thank you george okay well thank you again for your presentation and and uh our planning zoning members who joined us thank you as well as my colleagues on the council if there's nothing further i need a motion in a second so we can enjoy the meeting so moved by flores and ii made by councillor florida second by mayor pro tem gandana we adjourn uh christine are you there yeah can you call roll please yes sir this is on the motion to adjourn the meeting counselor abandons duby yes counselor vasquez i think he adjourned earlier counselor bancomo yeah counselor sorek yes councillor flores yes answer gandada yes mayor yes okay it's 5 15 pm we are adjourned thank you again everyone enjoy the rest of the day thank you mayor thank you everybody arrivederci ciao you